Human Resource Management
Free Business and Tech Magazines and eBooks
Custom Search

Alternative HRM models

Based on Human Resource Management, 4th edition, by Alan Price

The terminology used in academic human resource literature is problematic because some authors distinguish between 'the HRM model' as distinct from 'the Personnel model' (e.g. Bratton and Gould, 1999: 17) while others identify a number of different HRM models (including Bratton and Gould, a paragraph later).

Where do HRM models come from?

For the purposes of this discussion, we accept that there are numerous models and at least as many ways of classifying them - for example, 'hard and soft', 'normative and prescriptive'. Legge has produced a four-way classification, dividing models into the following types:

  • Normative
  • Descriptive-functional
  • Descriptive-behavioural
  • Critical evaluative

Tyson, on the other hand, has a three-way breakdown: normative, descriptive and analytical. Unfortunately, even these terms have contested meanings so that the Harvard model, for example, can be viewed as analyitcal or prescriptive - or a mixture of both.

Taking our analysis to its most basic level, we can consider HRM models from two fundamental perspectives:

  • What are the similarities between them?
  • Conversely, how do they differ?

Bratton and Gould (1999: 17) argue that: "Many of the key elements of the HRM model are drawn from organizational behaviour theories, such as motivation, team building and leadership." They go on to cite Legge (1989) as a reference for the assertion that 'most normative HRM models, whether US or British, assert that the organization's 'human resources' are valued assets, not a variable cost, and emphasise the commitment of employees as a source of competitive advantage.' They identify the classic theories of Maslow (1954) and Herzberg (1966) as being at the root of assumptions about the nature and exploitation of human potential while McGregor's Theory Y underpins notions of commitment and trust.

More articles in this section

HRM Textbooks

Human Resource Management

Human Resource Management, 4th edition
by Alan Price
 Covers all the key aspects of HRM. Available from:
Amazon.co.uk - UK pounds
Amazon.de - Euros
Amazon.fr - Euros
Amazon.it - Euros
Amazon.com - US dollars
Amazon.ca - Can dollars

Fundamentals of Human Resource Management

Fundamentals of Human Resource Management
 Shortened version of Human Resource Management - concise analysis for non-specialists and one-semester courses.
More information and prices from:
Amazon.co.uk - UK pounds
Amazon.de - Euros
Amazon.fr - Euros
Amazon.it - Euros
Amazon.com - US dollars
Amazon.ca - Can dollars

HRM Guide makes minimal use of cookies, including some placed to facilitate features such as Google Search. By continuing to use the site you are agreeing to the use of cookies. Learn more here

HRM Guide Updates
Custom Search

 
  Contact  HRM Guide Privacy Policy
Copyright © 1997-2017 Alan Price and HRM Guide Network contributors. All rights reserved.