This section considers
how employee performance can be evaluated and fostered. Assessment and
reward strategies are related to concepts of effective working behaviour.
The environmental context
The business environment
exercises both a direct and an indirect influence on the conduct of performance
assessment. Whereas legislation has specific consequences, particularly
in the USA, most environmental factors have a diffuse and often unrealized
effect on assessment and pay structures.
Business culture
Cultural norms dictate 'acceptable'
standards of performance and the management methods by which they are assured.
Legislation
Performance measurement
has become a sensitive legal issue in the USA because of possible consequences
on equal opportunities.
General economic conditions
At times
of high unemployment, workers are thought to be concerned about losing
their jobs and hence more conscientious and tolerant of strict management.
When suitable employees are scarce, managers must be cautious - unflattering
assessments can trigger an employee's move to another organization.
Industry sector
Considerable variation
is found between industry sectors due to the nature of work involved, tradition
and fashion. In some cases objectives are particularly difficult to measure.
Technological change
Developments in
IT are leading to significant changes in the measurement of performance.
Extensive statistics can be generated but how meaningful are they?
Flexibility and diversification
In the 1980s and early 90s, the nature of employment relationships in capitalist countries changed, moving the balance of power firmly in favour of employers. Performance assessment became the crucial means of monitoring this relationship. Job descriptions disappeared or were diluted, so that employees could be asked to do virtually anything required by the organisation. Conversely, performance criteria were more tightly defined, typically expressed in the form of demanding objectives: forever-moving goalposts.
Job descriptions are becoming looser but performance objectives are expected to be specific
and demanding. What are the consequences?
Employee relations
Performance-related
pay schemes emphasise the individual (or possibly teams), reducing the
role and influence of trade unions.
Workforce composition
What happens when
white, male supervisors assess the performance of women or members of ethnic
minorities?